Amateur built masts – Carbon and otherwise
Home › Forums › Technical – View only › Amateur built masts – Carbon and otherwise
- This topic has 8 replies, 4 voices, and was last updated 14 years, 8 months ago by
Martin Ward.
-
AuthorPosts
-
15th February 2012 at 8:40pm #865
Martin WardParticipantOne of the things I most like about the OK dinghy is that each part of it can be amateur built. I am under the impression that wooden, GPR, aluminum and carbon masts can currently be built be the amateur. Aluminum masts would be very difficult to build but with today’s TIG and MIG welders could be possible. I can remember in the original debate with the OK class regarding whether we should adopt carbon as a mast building material that there was talk of the possibility of home built carbon masts. The point here was that carbon masts could be built by the amateur much more easily that aluminum masts could have been built. It now looks like we are moving away from this amateur concept to professionally built masts to avoid the expensive ultra high modulus carbon. Of course I would not want an expensive form of carbon to be used in the OK class but isn’t there another way that the class could continue with amateur/home building and so avoid moving to a system of licensed mast builders.
I would really like to hear from OK sailors who have built there own masts and what material and method they used. I know that there are several Cherub videos on the subject of home built masts.
I think I am right in believing that the only International one design dinghies which can be built in their entirety by anyone are the Finn and the OK. This is a very rare position and it would be a shame to lose this option. Please point out if I have missed out any other classes.
Regards
Martin Ward
16th February 2012 at 8:00pm #5653
davecooperParticipantJust because you are an amateur wouldn’t stop you being a licensed builder, would it? Presumably all you’d have to do is to swear faithfully on a copy of the class rules that you weren’t going to make masts out of UHT and then you could make a mast.
JP Williams is the class expert on making carbon masts – he made a couple (? was it?) of masts back when they first came in: the track was faired in and they looked really nice. Much better looking than the selden masts that were the contemporary professional product. Dunno if JP ever reads this forum, or maybe someone else can fill you in with some technical detail.
Dave16th February 2012 at 8:25pm #5654
Martin WardParticipantDave
You have made a very good point. So what makes a license builder a license builder? Does this have to be approved by the International Sailing Federation?
I have been wondering about all the small classes of boats which are built in small numbers and may not be able to attract a license builder. These classes may also choose to go down the Carbon route and could find themselves priced out of the market. We may not be the only class facing this issue. I wonder what other classes do.
Regards
Martin Ward
16th February 2012 at 11:07pm #5655hughsheehy
ParticipantThe key thing for amateur construction of masts is the design and layup. It’s very non-trivial to calculate the correct layup for such a mast.
After that, perhaps the assoc could indeed licence an amateur builder….with requirement that a national measurer certify the materials used – or something similar.
A design, once made, could be licenced under a Creative Commons licence. Should be possible.
H
18th February 2012 at 5:40pm #5656
davecooperParticipantIt’s very non-trivial to calculate the correct layup for such a mast.
– just depends who you know!
I can’t help thinking that trying to source unidirectional prepreg in penny-packet quantities could be even more of an issue.@ Martin Ward – If they go this way I hope OKDIA would do the licensing. ISAF, wouldn’t they be very slow and bureaucratic? Might even want to charge a license fee or something!
Dave18th February 2012 at 8:41pm #5657hughsheehy
Participant@davecooper wrote:
– just depends who you know!
DaveSure, if you already know someone who knows the design and layup schedule. Calculating it from scratch isn’t a breeze, even if you’ve built masts before.
If there’s a usable, rights free design and layup schedule available, let’s have it!
H
19th February 2012 at 11:27am #5658
Martin WardParticipantWhat I would really like to see is a user guide showing a step by step method of making a carbon spar. A You Tube video would work well. The Cherub and DN Ice Yacht already do this. As a class we have booklets howing how to built an OK but as fas as I know nothing on how to built in Carbon let alone build Carbon Masts.
One of the point which we haven’t covered is repairs. Carbon Masts are meant to be repaired easily with more carbon. Will these repairs also be licensed. Presently I have a Proctor Aluminium mast which given the number of holes drilled in it may well break at deck or boom level. If amateur repairs are allowed in Carbon then this area could be strenghten with Carbon before I end up with a broken mast.
What if an amateur would like to replace the tip of their mast due to capsize damage. Carbon could really help repair this. Hopefully this point would not be licensed?
I would really like hear from anyone who has any technical information on mast building regardingless of the material involved.
Regards
Martin Ward
19th February 2012 at 9:58pm #5659
andyt15064ParticipantMartin – if your metal mast is really that dodgy I would strengthen it with carbon now.
Andy
26th February 2012 at 1:08pm #5660
Martin WardParticipantAndy
I will probably Tig weld up my Poctor Mast but would like to make myself a new Mast in the future. Unfortunately I have a lost of tasks to do before I can get around to this.
It would be really interested to see photos of how the halyard feeds out of the mast above the Mast ring on other OK’s. I was wondering if anyone would want to post any photos of Halyard holes in their Mast.
Regards
Martin Ward
-
AuthorPosts
- The forum ‘Technical – View only’ is closed to new topics and replies.













