Europeans in Germany
Home › Forums › Gossip – View only › Europeans in Germany
- This topic has 46 replies, 17 voices, and was last updated 12 years, 3 months ago by
Ken.
-
AuthorPosts
-
12th March 2014 at 12:06pm #1133
andyt15064ParticipantTime to start planning for this. Not many Brits have indicated they are coming so far but it’s bound to be an excellent event with added German hospitality. Entry forms to me by the end of May. Transfer the £ equivalent of 200 Euros to the IOKDBCA account at the same time (details of the exchange rate to follow nearer the time)
While i’m on about the Europeans I’d like to raise a gripe about rule observance and the usefulness (or otherwise) of the jury. A jury is the most expensive item at the Worlds but I don’t think we paid the full amount at the Europeans in Carnac as it was deemed a “Euro cup event” . However they were out on the water and occasionally waved a yellow flag. There was a lot of rule breaking/bending going on. The two most common I saw/experienced were people coming across on port and tacking right in front so that the right of way boat had to tack away before the port tack boat had completed it’s tack. Also a lot of barging in late at marks, particularly the windward mark with port tack boats coming in within 3 boat lengths of the mark and tacking on to starboard, forcing starboard tack boats to luff up.
I asked the jury why they didn’t wave any flags at these clear infringements and they told me they were only out there to police rule 42. Surely if we pay good money to these people and it’s a Euro Cup event, as it will be in Germany, we can ask them to broaden their remit to cover other clear rule infringements. Admittedly we don’t want excessive whistling and flag waving but rule observance is getting out of hand, mostly towards the front of the fleet.
Maybe OKDIA would care to comment?
Andy
12th March 2014 at 12:35pm #7298
KenParticipantI would support Andy on this request/suggestion. There is nothing worse than setting yourself up and gaining clear air only to be tacked under/in front of so closely your the one having to take avoiding action. And even at the Alton water frost bite, the number of boats crashing in on port at the windward mark made a mockery of those trying to sail to the rules and set themselves up for a decent rounding. If we are to pay for the jury why not expect them to observe and enforce rules.
12th March 2014 at 1:35pm #7299
FinnParticipantIn fear of being unpopular…..is this not what we have a protest procedure for?
If you don’t like someones conduct on the water, then protest them.
12th March 2014 at 1:44pm #7300hughsheehy
Participant@Finn wrote:
In fear of being unpopular…..is this not what we have a protest procedure for?
If you don’t like someones conduct on the water, then protest them.
Bring a camera then! Or at least two witnesses.
H
12th March 2014 at 1:47pm #7301
KenParticipant@Finn wrote:
In fear of being unpopular…..is this not what we have a protest procedure for?
If you don’t like someones conduct on the water, then protest them.
Of course you are correct. But we all know that is easier said than done. What Andy is suggesting is if we are to pay for a Jury why can we not expect their assistance in enforcing cleaner sailing. I would have thought the threat of this level of monitoring might have some effect on those thinking of getting away with it. I am sure we are all guilty at some time or the other. Plus we all more often than not get away with it, so therefore we continue to do it. But that don’t make it right.
12th March 2014 at 2:10pm #7302
FinnParticipantI agree that it is easier said than done – which I think is largely due to the [perceived] social implications of such action.
I however, disagree that an omnipresent jury would solve the problem. I think it is much more effective to have of your peers call foul.
At Carnac last year I was involved in a discussion where it was suggested (by Bo Peterson I think) that loads of protests is a bad thing and no protests is equally bad – there needs to be a healthy level of protesting within the fleet. I agree.
12th March 2014 at 4:58pm #7303
burtParticipantin reply to the initial thread idea…. am definitely going to the euros might be an idea to bring some forms along for people to fill out there and then?
12th March 2014 at 9:20pm #7304
GBR1501ParticipantI think its all apart of the race… “self umpiring”…and learning the rules, relevance and when to speak out for oneself…. having a jury only “clouds” things….lol… :roll:
oh and Andy you appear to have “observed” a lot or rule infringing….
I’m afraid I wont be able to attend the Euros alas this year …. but I’m sure it will be a good event :mrgreen:
12th March 2014 at 11:22pm #7305
robertParticipantFrom the ISAF judges manual
“F.2.2.1
Notice of Race
The notice of race must state that on-the-water judging may/or will be used in the regatta.F.2.2.2
Sailing Instructions
A specific section must be added to the sailing instructions to inform the competitors that on-the-water judging will be used. The procedure must be placed in the sailing
instructions with a separate numbered paragraph that clearly states how the competitors will be informed that a rule has been broken.”That hasn’t been stated in the NoR so we can’t do it this year. As I understand it the IJ is basically a protest committee given further powers in the NoR and SI. The NoR just mentions appendix P (rule 42 judging). They can’t start waving flags at other incidents though of course they can act as witnesses and protest infringements they see. [I’m sure someone will correct me on this…]
Bottom line. Protest them. [Or T-bone them.] As you know I’ve done both and, either way, they won’t do it again.
13th March 2014 at 3:52pm #7306
GregParticipantAs Robert has said it is not in the NOR however I agree with Andy that we pay for the jury so they should at the very least be useful.Although they can’t actually apply on the water judging there is nothing to stop the class asking them to do something. It should not be a problem for them to use their whistles and a red flag when they see an incident that they think breaks one or more rules. Then it could be up to the competitors involved to either go to the protest room about it if they believe they are all right or for someone to do some turns. The Jury cannot give an on the water penalty but can indicate they saw a rule broken and wait for someone to exonerate themselves. They can also protest the boat involved if they wish and in fact they should if they believe rules were broken.
The idea of this is to keep the onus on the competitors to uphold the rules or take a penalty if they accidentally break one. In effect it changes nothing from what we should be sailing by anyway however it can act to promote penalty taking.
Perhaps the best idea is for this to be raised with Ossi as not only is he an International Judge but he is chief organiser as well and knows the jury very well. This can come from the association or from OKDIA. Personally I think it is a great idea.
I have to say though that if Andy thinks there are more rules broken at the front of the fleet he is dreaming. Most of the top guys show a lot of respect not only for each other but also for sailing fairly and within the rules. More problems occur with those who are not so sure of the rules. Remember also that a protest should never be personal. It is merely a disagreement over who is right or wrong and the jury is there to make that decision.
Also if you do as Robert suggests and T-bone someone it is very hard to say you tried to avid a collision and you can also be disqualified!13th March 2014 at 6:57pm #7307
leechParticipant[/quote]Also if you do as Robert suggests and T-bone someone it is very hard to say you tried to avid a collision and you can also be disqualified!
You’re right always take their rudder off the back, then at least you’ve tried to bear away!!
13th March 2014 at 8:13pm #7308
robertParticipantI have a reputation to uphold…
13th March 2014 at 10:51pm #7309
FinnParticipantAs Hugh was maybe trying to point out, many a ligit protest has lost it’s legs through lack of reliable witnesses.
Perhaps having Observer boats stationed at the marks (separate to the Rule 42 jury) who could then be called upon as impartial witnesses could work well. This wouldn’t mean putting extra jury boats on the water as the saftey boats are often milling about. The observers don’t need to be jury as all they are asked to do is recount events, not make judgements.
Would this need to be in the NOR? I don’t think so because anyone who saw an incident can be called as a witness.
14th March 2014 at 10:27am #7310
andyt15064ParticipantQuite right Finn. Anyone in a jury boat who saw the incident could also be asked to be a witness.
Hardly any protests occur because it is difficult to get a witness and is therefore your word against theirs – and no protest committee is going to disqualify a boat under those circumstances.
Andy
15th March 2014 at 6:37am #7311
NickCraigParticipantHi all,
Whilst I can’t do the Europeans this year, I completely agree with Andy’s thinking
Finn is right that in an ideal world self-policing would be effective. But in practice, protests waste beer time and outcomes can be pretty random. Even with reliable witnesses as Turtle and I know from a trip to Goa!! So protests tend to happen only for the more extreme incidents
Jury’s are pricey so we should certainly be asking them to be as active as possible (assuming they are competent!)Cheers
Nick -
AuthorPosts
- The forum ‘Gossip – View only’ is closed to new topics and replies.













