hull shapes – differences
Home › Forums › Technical – View only › hull shapes – differences
- This topic has 6 replies, 3 voices, and was last updated 13 years, 7 months ago by
hughsheehy.
-
AuthorPosts
-
11th February 2013 at 9:22pm #1009
hughsheehy
Participanthi,
Last year I read the section on the UK site about the difference between hull shapes. This page. http://www.okdia.org/technical/manual/tm5_hull.php…you’ve probably all read it.
Earlier this evening I thought “wait – I can overlay those images on my pc” so i made the images transparent and did just that. The differences in hull shape are, shall we say, small.
About the only difference I can see that could mean anything is the slightly greater width of the Hoare at the chine under the mast….the famous full bow. Other than that – very little. The thickness of the line in the drawings is bigger than the difference in shape.
The three images are just overlaid in the google docs file here https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1zi1UdtIyIj7XPFih7XuPlGLTSvTxHAMrECU8Sn7ve0c/edit?usp=sharing. You can move them about and see where there are any shape differences. (either copy the file to your own account or leave it as you found it so that the next person can play too.)
The skinner and rose shapes seem VERY similar if not practically identical. Any difference in feel between two boats would probably be the exact position and bend curve of the mast or the centreboard bolt rather than differences between the hull shapes – except perhaps that full bow is probably noticeable even if it doesn’t make much speed difference. Even then the exact place you prop your butt is probably as important.
Same old story then, eh? The skipper, rig, foils, hull…are important, in that order. TO quote an old windsurfing video..”Just rig it and sail it.”
H
11th February 2013 at 10:22pm #6559
Si CoxParticipantHi Hugh.
Interesting if a little simplistic. A lot of the design isn’t what happens at the stations but what happens in between and panel curvature. Having seen a few different Dave Rose designs as well as Icebreakers, Rushworths and Heins recently its quite striking how different they all are to the naked eye. We had John Ball’s new boat (an older Dave Rose design) and the Synergy plug (skipper/rose) next to each other a few weeks ago and they almost looked different classes despite both being within tolerances.
It’s one of the many great attributes of the OK class. As you suggest the trick is getting all components to work together across a wide wind range. Most championships are over a week and experience a wide range of conditions. Too many designs focus too much on a given range or top speed at the detriment of ease of handling or down speed/acceleration.
Cheers
Simon11th February 2013 at 10:25pm #6560
burtParticipantnot an expert in the subject but a good realisation process was the measurement process in Sweden where terry was kind enough to point out the difference between an icebreaker and a delf.
at the measurement points there is virtually no difference (and it is very hard to see) the main difference is between how the panels were shaped the delf has curved panels and the icebreaker flat.
it was pretty interesting to see and with my current boat the curves are very extreme, a Dave rose wood foam wood boat, (no pictures as it is currently in transit) especially when it is sat next to toms O’Donnell shape which is pretty much at the opposite end of the scale.
I think a lot of the difference with the current shapes is the panels rather then the measurement points.
someone may correct me but thats my thinking
12th February 2013 at 11:27am #6561
Si CoxParticipantNail on head Burt.
12th February 2013 at 3:26pm #6562hughsheehy
ParticipantI didn’t think that sticking the pictures over each other was anything other than simplistic, to be fair.
If burt’s boat is the one I remember from Pitsford, it’s the one with the funny tucks at the transom….and that’s definitely a different shape.
twas just interesting to line the three shapes laid over each other and see.
I have a hoare and have only sailed the Rowsell that we have here too. They feel completely different to sail, but they sound different and have different foils and rigs so I always wonder what’s the main source of that different feeling.
The hoare has visibly curved panels, where the Rowsell mostly doesn’t. But the difference is litres of volume over a good chunk of the hull length. Does it make a speed difference?
Is an O’Donnell slower than a skipper/rose or a hoare or an icebreaker? I don’t know. Seeing all the different builders in the top 20 it seems that no-one is sure! At least as long as the hulls are at the sensible edge of the tolerances…
H
1st April 2013 at 10:02pm #6563hughsheehy
ParticipantHere’s an interesting recent article on the same topic from the Aussies.
http://www.ok.yachting.org.au/?Page=65832
H
14th April 2013 at 5:47pm #6564hughsheehy
ParticipantAnd here’s a fascinating photo of an upside-down Hoare. Them ain’t flat panels!!
H
-
AuthorPosts
- The forum ‘Technical – View only’ is closed to new topics and replies.













